Last week a sponsor asked me a question. Several lenders had passed on his acquisition because of size. If he raised the debt ask from $6 million to $7 million and parked the extra $1 million as cash on the balance sheet after closing, would those lenders come back?
My answer was that most of them would not. A slightly bigger ask does not move the needle. What can change things is a credible plan to put materially more capital to work: roughly $5 to $10 million more over the next couple of years, through add-on acquisitions.
Here is how we got there, and what "credible" has to mean.
The deal sits at the edge
The deal is a lower middle market acquisition with a $6.0 million senior debt ask against $3 million of trailing twelve-month adjusted EBITDA, backed by a quality of earnings report. That is a reasonable deal. It is also small for a lot of the lenders who do this kind of financing.
The lenders that passed on size had this feedback:
1. One lender's floor is a facility size well above this ask.
2. One said the revenue level was below its threshold.
3. One said the company was below its typical $10 million revenue threshold. It added that it can make an exception to one of its criteria, and it had other concerns as well.
4. One said "too small" and named no metric.
Other lenders continue to review.
Why $1 million more won't move the needle
Size screens come in two kinds, and an extra $1 million of debt misses both.
A facility floor measures the loan. When a lender's floor is well above the ask, going from $6 million to $7 million still leaves the ask well short of it.
Revenue and EBITDA minimums measure the business. Parking $1 million of loan proceeds as cash changes neither. The company earns what it earned before, and the lender sees the same business it already passed on.
The lender that said "too small" never named a metric, so we cannot say what would clear it.
Going back to the same lenders with a $7 million ask would spend time in the process while the seller waits, and most of them would give the same answer.
What can move it: a plan to deploy $5 to $10 million more
Lenders weigh the whole relationship, including what it could become.
A credible plan to deploy roughly $5 to $10 million more over the next couple of years, through add-on acquisitions, could change that picture. That matters most for lenders near the edge of their range, like the one that put this deal at the small end of its size range. A growth plan will not answer other underwriting concerns, but it could make the relationship big enough to be worth a closer look.
The $1 million bump asks a lender to accept the same business with more debt. The add-on plan offers a lender a bigger business to finance over time.
That is our read, and it depends on the plan being real.
What makes an add-on plan credible
Before we put an add-on plan in front of lenders, it needs to cover four things:
1. Targets. The actual companies you would buy, or a specific profile of them.
2. Pipeline. Where those targets come from and how far along the conversations are.
3. Timing. When each add-on is expected to close over the next couple of years.
4. Funding. How each one gets paid for, and how much of it is new debt.
Consistency matters as much as the plan. If add-ons were played down on earlier lender calls, a sudden add-on story could read as a pitch to get over a size hurdle. Build the plan first, make sure it matches what lenders have already heard, and only then put it in front of them.
Our read
Here is how I put it to the sponsor: "Bumping the ask by $1M that goes to balance-sheet cash won't move most lenders."
Size minimums measure the loan and the business. An extra $1 million leaves this ask well short of the facility floor and leaves the business the same size. A credible plan to grow the business, and the borrowing with it, can.
If your deal is getting passes on size, what would your add-on plan look like on paper?
Tell a Friend
If you received this newsletter from a friend, don't miss out on future insights. Subscribe now at thefinancingflow.net to receive weekly issues directly to your inbox.
To your financing success!
